Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ICAM Presentation1 ILversion 01.1
ICAM Presentation1 ILversion 01.1
Day 1
Assemb
ly
Area
Before we start…
Page 4
Course Overview - 2 Day Programe
• Welcome, Safety Brief, Attendance Register
• Getting to know each other
• Course Aspects
– Context and Purpose (day 1)
– Learning objectives (day 1)
– Causes and Consequences of Incidents (day 1)
– Definitions (day 1)
– Interviewing techniques (day 1)
– 7-Step ICAM Method and Tools (day 1)
– Review of day 1 (day 2)
– Case Studies (Syndicated exercises) (day 2)
• Your Expectations?
• Rules of the Game?
• Parking Lot
• Plus Delta
• Course Evaluation
Page 5
Learning Objectives
• Upon completion of this course you will be able to:
– Recognise the need for an incident investigation
– Gather and organise relevant data
– Interview witnesses using key steps
– Carry out an ICAM investigation
• ICAM Objectives
– Establish the facts surrounding the event
– Identify contributing factors and underlying causes
– Review the adequacy of existing controls and procedures
– Recommend preventive and corrective actions
– Report the findings in order to share key learnings
– Not to apportion blame or liability to individuals or teams
Page 6
“I’m Gonna Live Until I Die”
Page 8
What We Do Not Understand,
We Cannot Control Charles Reich
Page 9
Cost Of Loss Iceberg
Page 10
Accident Causation Theory
Page 11
Accident Causation Theory
Page 12
Accident Causation Model
Swiss Cheese Model
developed by psychologist and human error expert
Hazards P ro Professor James Reason
blem
solvi
ng Path
way
Organisational
Factors
Task/ Env
Factors
Co Individual
n
Inc tribu
Incident
id
ent t ing or Team
C aus F act Actions
at ion or s Absent / Failed
P ath
w Defences
ay
Page 13
Accident Causation Theory
Page 14
Error Tolerance
Page 16
"To achieve progress every accident and
incident, no matter how minor, must be
considered as a failure of the system, or
organisation and not simply as the failure of a
person, or of people."
Dan Maurino, ICAO
Page 17
HSEC performance improvement strategies
Prevention FACTORS
Error
Trapping
Error
Mitigation
Zero Fatalities
to
Zero Harm
Page 18
Page 19
Page 20
ICAM Investigation Guideline
http://hsec.bhpbilliton.net/bp/safety/icam.asp
Page 21
What is ICAM?
Page 22
ICAM Investigations
Investigations are
like football, a lot
depends on how you
view the game and
the result you want
Descriptive level
Continual
Improvement of
The Game
Target Achieved !
Rating Chart
Page 29
What can we do with ICAM ?
Task /
Organisational Environ. Individual/ Absent / failed
Factors conditions Team actions Defences No Incidents
Page 33
Definitions
• Incident - Any occurrence that has resulted in, or has the potential to
result in (i.e. near miss), adverse consequences to people, the
environment, property, reputation, or a combination of these. Significant
deviations from standard operating procedures are also classed as an
‘incident’. Ongoing conditions that have the potential to result in adverse
consequences are considered to be incidents.
• Near miss – Any occurrence or a situation which potentially could have
caused adverse consequences to people, the environment, property or
reputation, or a combination of these but which did not.
• Hazard – A source of potential harm, injury or detriment.
Page 34
ICAM Methodology Overview
Page 35
ICAM Methodology Overview (contd)
Page 36
W h at w w r o n g ?
en t r i g h W h
t? a t w en t
Why Investigate ?
Incident Investigation
Fact-Finding,
Not Fault- Finding
Page 39
Why do we investigate incidents ?
Page 40
Goals for incident investigations
Page 41
Qualities of Investigators
Integrity Imaginative
Objectivity Humility
Perseverance Intuition
Curiosity Tact
Observing Skill
Page 42
Investigator’s Performance Test
Page 45
Collecting Information
• People
• Environment
• Equipment
• Procedures
• Organisation
Page 46
Collecting Information
equipment, chemicals, feed-stock and other raw material, products, and supplies.
• Environment – All parts of the surroundings for the people at work as well as the
surroundings in which the site operates, including air, water, land, natural resources,
Page 47
Collecting Information
• Procedures – Production and work methods used to produce the end product or
service. Procedure usually relate to actual physical processes; however with the
• Organisation – Management holds the legal responsibility for the safety of the
workplace and workforce. Role profiles are developed and clearly defined.
Page 48
Collecting Information
• Identify conditions, actions, or deficiencies in each
of the PEEPO categories
• These could be contributing factors to the incident
• Ask broad questions: who, what, where,
when,why,why,why…..
Page 49
Significant Incident Reports – what do they look like?
Page 50
Incident reconstruction (re-enactment)
Page 51
Dangers of Incident Reconstruction (re-enactment)
Oh Bugger!!
Page 52
ICAM involves 7 steps
Page 53
Page 54
Page 55
Page 56
Page 57
Page 58
Page 59
Page 60
Page 61
Page 62
Page 63
DIFFICULT
Ease of Change
QUICK WINS COMPETITIVE
NEED
EASY
LOW HIGH
Pay-off / Impact
Page 64
DIFFICULT
Ease of Change
QUICK WINS COMPETITIVE
NEED
EASY
LOW HIGH
Pay-off / Impact
Page 65
DIFFICULT
Ease of Change
QUICK WINS COMPETITIVE
NEED
EASY
LOW HIGH
Pay-off / Impact
Page 66
7-Step
I nvestig
ation P
r ocess
Page 67
ICAM Step 1
2. Investigation Planning
3. Data Collection
4. Data Organisation
5. ICAM Analysis
Page 68
Step 1: Immediate Actions
1. Immediate
Actions
• These are the things that should be done immediately following an incident.
2. Investigation
Planning
• Emergency Response
3. Data
Collection
– Make sure hazards are addressed (Hierarchy of Controls)
4. Data
Organisation
• Securing the Site
5. ICAM
Analysis
– Make the site safe
6. Preventive &
Corrective
– PRESERVE THE INCIDENT SITE
Actions
7. Report the
– Identify and implement immediate corrective actions to prevent further
findings
incidents
– Drug and Alcohol test
– Notify Management
– Photograph, Video, Measure, Draw, Survey, etc.
– Document emergency response actions for analysis later
– Complete initial Incident Report
3. Data
Collection • Team members should not be placed in situation for
4. Data
Organisation
potential conflict
5. ICAM
Analysis
6. Preventive &
Corrective
Actions
• Members must have time made available
7. Report the
findings
Page 70
Appoint Investigation Team – get the right people
Investigation Team
Position Description
Positions
Independent Senior Line Manager or best qualified
Team Leader
person with the appropriate experience and skills
Senior Site Representative Senior Line Manager
Senior HSE or Line Manager with ICAM facilitation
ICAM Facilitator
skills
Technical Specialist Specific skills relevant to investigation
Other Independent
Independent subject matter experts
Members
Page 71
ICAM Step 2
1. Immediate Actions
3. Data Collection
4. Data Organisation
5. ICAM Analysis
Page 72
Step 2: Investigation Planning
1. Immediate
Actions Appointed Investigation Team to:
• Attend overview by management
2. Investigation
Planning
3. Data
4. Data
Organisation
5. ICAM
Analysis • Plan the investigation (Including site visit)
6. Preventive &
Corrective
Actions
• Locate Investigation Room that is not going to be disturbed
7. Report the
Page 73
Time Table – investigations require time
1. Immediate
Actions
2. Investigation
Planning
Activity versus Time Taken
Corrective
3. Data
Collection
Data Collection Data ICAM Preventive Report
Actions
4. Data
Organisation
Organisation
Total
Potential SI 2 days ½ day ½ day ½ day ½ day 4 days
5. ICAM
Analysis
6. Preventive &
Corrective
Actions
7. Report the
Note: not all team members are involved at all of the stages above and the times are indicative only
Page 74
ICAM Step 3
1. Immediate Actions
2. Investigation Planning
4. Data Organisation
5. ICAM Analysis
Page 75
Step 3: Data Collection
1. Immediate
Actions • Gather relevant facts
• Understanding what happened
2. Investigation
Planning
3. Data
4. Data
Organisation
5. ICAM
Analysis
– People
6. Preventive &
Corrective
Actions
– Environment
7. Report the
findings – Equipment
– Procedures and Documents
– Organisation
Page 76
Data Collection – what it looks like
Data Category Collection Method
P People
E Environment
n s to r m
t o b rai llec t
E EP O to c o
E Equipment
P
Use a you nee ageable d
a t da t o m a n
wh k it in t
to b r ea n k s
P Procedures or c h u
O Organisation
Page 77
Data Collection: People Category
1. Immediate
2. Investigation
Planning
4. Data
Organisation
5. ICAM
Analysis – People Involved
6. Preventive &
7. Report the
findings
Page 78
Why interview Witnesses?
1. Immediate
Actions • To allow information to be gathered about the incident
2. Investigation
Planning
3. Data
Collection
• Interviews should be carried out as soon as possible to
4. Data
Organisation prevent bias
5. ICAM
Analysis
6. Preventive &
Corrective
Actions
• They are not for legal purposes
7. Report the
findings
Page 79
Legal Guidelines for ICAM Investigations
1. Immediate
Actions
4. Data
Organisation
5. ICAM
and the Company.
Analysis
6. Preventive &
Corrective
Where a fatality or serious injury has occurred, it is particularly
important that BHP Billiton Legal is contacted prior to the taking of
Actions
7. Report the
witness statements.
findings
Page 80
Legal Guidelines for ICAM Investigations
Page 81
Interviewing Techniques for Investigators
Witness Types
• Operators
• Work colleagues
• Family members
• Industry personnel
• Members of the general public
Page 83
Interview Techniques
1. Immediate
Actions
• Identify key witnesses and prioritise whom to interview first
2. Investigation
Planning
(if statements have not already been taken)
3. Data
Collection
4. Data
• Interview individually
Organisation
5. ICAM
Analysis • Let them do most of the talking
6. Preventive &
Corrective
• Consider expertise
Actions
7. Report the
findings
• Assess credibility
• Record the interview (with permission)
• Follow-up if necessary
• Health and Safety (Or Union) Representative can be present
• Witnesses should be available during the investigation to clarify
information for the investigation team
Page 84
Hierarchy of Questioning Techniques
Examples :
Unstructured free recall “In your own words can you tell me what
happened”
Open-ended questions “What happened then?”
Encouraging responses “Uh-huh”, head nod, eye contact etc.
Paraphrasing “You’re saying he was quite upset about
failing the exam?”
Closed Questions “Exactly where were you standing?”
(Multiple Choice)
Leading “You’re saying he had a history of taking
short-cuts to be able to finish early?”
Questions
• You have two ears and one mouth. Use them in that ratio
Page 85
Example Questions
Adequate Inadequate
“Can you tell me where you were last night “You were watching the football in the crib
and what you were doing?” room weren’t you?”
“Can you run me through what occurred Did you cause the incident?
during night shift leading up to the incident
from your location?”
“So just let me run through what you have “I’ll run through the story and you can tell me
told me so far. You saw…” (at the end of the if I have got it right”. (at the beginning of the
interview) interview)
Page 86
Brain Teasers
Page 87
What Do You See?
Page 88
What Do You See?
Page 89
What Do You See?
Page 90
What Do You See?
Page 91
ALZHEIMERS' EYE TEST
Page 92
ALZHEIMERS' EYE TEST
Page 93
Can you read this?
it deosn't mttaer in waht oredr the ltteers in a wrod are, the olny
iprmoatnt tihng is taht the frist and lsat ltteer be in the rghit
pclae. The rset can be a taotl mses and you can sitll raed it
wouthit a porbelm.
Tihs is bcuseae the huamn mnid deos not raed ervey lteter by
istlef, but the wrod as a wlohe. Amzanig huh? yaeh and I awlyas
tghuhot slpeling was ipmorantt!
Page 94
Page 95
Page 96
Page 97
What do you see?
Page 98
What you see depends on what you are concentrating on.
Page 99
Witness Interviewing
Page 100
Perceptions Differ
Page 101
Perceptions Differ
Page 102
Limitations to the accuracy of eyewitness testimony
Stimulus factors
(event characteristics)
Personality and
perceptual factors
Elapsed
time since
MEMORY the event
Page 103
Limitations to the accuracy of eyewitness testimony
External
MEMORY Information
Personality and
motivational factors
Communication
(interviewing) factors
RECALL/OUTPUT
‘THE TESTIMONY’
Page 104
Are all witnesses reliable?
1. Immediate
Actions
2. Investigation
There were two planes, but
the sun was in my eyes
Planning
3. Data
Collection
4. Data
Organisation
5. ICAM
Analysis
6. Preventive &
Corrective
Actions
7. Report the
findings
Page 105
General Principles
– Preparation Is everything
1. Immediate
Actions
2. Investigation
Planning
3. Data
Collection – Timeliness Memories are perishable
4. Data
Organisation
5. ICAM
Analysis
– Location Use environmental cues to aid recall
6. Preventive &
7. Report the
findings
Page 106
Commencing the Interview
• Set the right tone for co-operation:
1. Immediate
Actions
2. Investigation
Planning
3. Data
Collection
– Introduce yourself
Use a non-threatening environment
4. Data
Organisation
–
5. ICAM
Analysis
6. Preventive &
Corrective
– Establish a rapport with the witness
Actions
7. Report the
findings
– Describe your role in the investigation
– Describe the purpose of the interview
– Ask permission to take notes during the interview
Page 107
Activity 1: Interviewing Techniques
Context:
• Incident investigation requires relevant facts to be gathered to understand the incident and
the events which led to the incident. Witnesses can provide a lot of the facts.
Purpose:
• To conduct an interview about what the other person has just seen in a DVD
Quality:
• Using the interview techniques discussed, perform an interview on a witness
Quantity:
• 1 interview performed (in pairs)
Resources:
• Work in a group of 2 – 1witness, 1 interviewer
• ICAM Investigation Guideline and Training Manual
• Trainers Handouts
• DVD watched whilst you were outside
Time:
• 30 minutes
Page 108
Interviewing Exercise
2. Investigation
• Purpose to consider what environmental conditions were evident
Planning
3. Data
Collection at the time of the incident
4. Data
5. ICAM
Analysis
6. Preventive &
Corrective
Actions
– Weather conditions
– Time of the day
7. Report the
findings
– Housekeeping
– Conditions such as noises and lighting
– Dust, fumes, toxic substances
– Photographs of the scene prior to disassembly
– Time Pressures
Page 110
Data Collection: Equipment Category
1. Immediate
Actions • During an investigation seek out possible causes resulting from
2. Investigation
Planning equipment and materials being used:
3. Data
Collection
4. Data
– What materials were being used
Organisation
5. ICAM
Analysis – Damage to equipment
6. Preventive &
7. Report the
findings
Page 111
Data Collection: Procedures and Documents Category
1. Immediate
Actions • Examine documents used at the time of incident to see if they
2. Investigation
Planning contributed to the incident:
3. Data
– Safe Operating Procedures – was there one, was the correct one being
Collection
4. Data
Organisation
5. ICAM
used, was it known?
Analysis
6. Preventive &
Corrective
Actions
– JSA / THA / JHA etc.
7. Report the
findings
– Training and medical records
– Material Safety Data Sheets (MSDS)
– Permit to Work
– Equipment manuals and procedures
– Incident reports, audit reports and inspection reports
Page 112
Data Collection: Organisation Category
1. Immediate
Actions • Management’s responsibility to provide a safe workplace must
2. Investigation
Planning be considered during an investigation and lead to questions such
3. Data
Collection
as:
4. Data
Organisation
5. ICAM
Analysis
– How are safety rules communicated?
6. Preventive &
7. Report the
findings
Page 113
Example 1: PEEPO
Data Category Collection Method
E Environment
Inspect the area Time pressure? Time of Difficult area to Normal job role
day/roster/shifts work? or practice
E Equipment
Equipment Isolation
choice? device Warning
signs?
P Procedures
Training Work Isolation
Records Procedure? Risk
Assessment Procedure
O Organisation
Page 115
Investigations can be messy… Example of PEEPO
Assign responsibilities to
PEEPO. Decide who
needs to collect what?
Page 116
Activity 1: PEEPO
Data Category Collection Method
Interview TA Interview Training,
P People Position of Statement from
– Lower and supervisor workers witness (3rd Quals,
Upper person) Experience
E Equipment
Inspect Check protection Available
Helmet used equipment
P Procedures
Review Risk SIMOPS Procedures
Review JSA /
Assessment THA for the task procedure available and
used?
O Organisation
How is What supervision
training is provided HSEC
provided on Communic-ation
SIMOPS
Page 118