Professional Documents
Culture Documents
JSF: A Preliminary Assessment: Bill Sweetman
JSF: A Preliminary Assessment: Bill Sweetman
JSF: A Preliminary Assessment: Bill Sweetman
Bill Sweetman
Aerospace & Technology Editor Janes Information Group October 26, 2006
October 26, 2006 1
B-2
Plan: 132 aircraft Outcome: 21 aircraft with chronic problems
A-12
Plan: 1,200 aircraft for USAF/USN Cancelled 1991
V-22
Development started 1984 IOC 2007? Unit cost $100 million
F/A-18E/F
Met cost and schedule Range, agility below expectations
JSF: economics
Cost Then-year average procurement cost (based on GAO)
F-35A - $76 m F-35B - $109 m F-35C - $112 m
O&S costs remain to be proven Acquisition cost advantage is based on numbers and rates There is no free lunch
10
11
12
13
JSF: Armament
Weapon load-out Four usable stations in LO mode
SDB is only way to carry more than four weapons No mixed load-outs without SDB Cant trade bombs for AAMs
14
15
JSF stealth
Stealth is important Day one stealth concept based on GW1 But limited warload = more sorties What if defenses are not destroyed?
Only 10 per cent of systems were destroyed in Allied Force
Non-LO mode No indications that signature is managed Active EW? Towed decoy?
October 26, 2006 16
A question
?
And do we mean a USAF F-35A? An RAF F-35A? A Turkish F-35A?
17
Stealth questions
Detection developments since 1980 Networking increases value of transient detection HF and ultrawideband radars Passive bistatic radars Passive detection and datalinks Track-before-detect facilitated by memory Tracking developments since 1980 AESA
18
Competition
Typhoon Highly capable air-to-air Higher acceleration and three times the missile load Unproven air-to-ground Firm order base larger than F-22 or F/A-18 Rafale Beats F-35 range/payload with two-thirds the OEW Needs AESA/Meteor Needs French government backing Gripen Proven low-cost solution
October 26, 2006 19
10X volume for support and upgrades Even if the program gets cut in half, its 125/year Nobody got fired for buying IBM F-16, F/A-18 exports did what it said on the tin
20
Conclusion
There are markets for other aircraft The F-35 does not surpass every competitor in all respects We are five years into a 12-year development program US track record is not good The game is not over
21