Intrapreneurship in Hospitality and Tourism Class #8
Dr. Adam Weaver
School of Hospitality and Tourism Niagara College Canada The Lean Canvas Model: Cost Structure and Revenue Streams Today’s Key Questions • What costs are associated with the creation of a business? • What factors should entrepreneurs keep in mind when calculating the amount of money they will need for their start-up investment? • What are fixed costs and what are variable costs? How are they different from each other? • How do businesses generate revenue? Cost of Operating a Business • To run a successful business, you need to determine and keep track of costs • Cash coming in should exceed the cash going out • Typically, we sell products and services for more than they cost • You are probably aiming to earn a profit (social enterprises can be an exception) Examples of Costs • Many costs are associated with the establishment and growth of a small business • These costs include start-up purchases, fixed costs, variable costs, and cash reserves • How much money will you need to establish your business? • Start-up investment, or seed capital, is the one-time expense of opening a business Start-Up Investment • Start-up investment, or seed capital, is the one-time expense of opening a business • In the case of a restaurant, start-up expenses would include stoves, food processors, tables, chairs, silverware, and other items that would not be replace very often • Also included might be the one-time cost of purchasing land and constructing a building • It might be wise, at first, to rent a property and even (kitchen) equipment Start-Up Investment • Some entrepreneurs choose to consider the amount of time they put into getting their business off the group • This time sunk into business development becomes part of the start-up investment • To do so, place a value on your own time per hour and multiply by the number of hours you think you will be spending to get your business going • Remember that the time spent developing your business is time that you would not be able to work for an employer in order to earn money Start-Up Investment: Hot Dog Stand • For a hot dog stand, the start-up investment might be as follows: • Hot dog cart = $3,000 • Business licenses = $100 • Business cards and flyers = $200 • Beginning inventory (hot dogs, buns, mustard, and other condiments) = $100 • Cash box and other = $100 • Total start-up investment without contingency = $3,500 • Contingency: 10% of start-up investment = $350 • Total start-up investment with contingency = $3,850 The Value of Brainstorming • Try to anticipate every possible cost • You could talk to other business owners in your industry (please do not contact other businesses for this course) • You could ask these business owners: What costs did you fail to anticipate? • You may discover, for example, that you need licenses and insurance that you did not expect • To address contingencies and emergencies, add 10 percent to your total estimate Research the Costs • You can also do some research to assess your start-up costs • To what extent are there business plan models for the industry you have chosen? • You may need to adapt the cost data to fit your business and obtain quotations on pricing from potential suppliers • You do not want to be caught by surprise about costs that you could have predicted • Remember to reference the sources that you use Think, Pair, Share • Meet with the other students from your project group for 5 minutes. What are the costs associated with starting up your proposed business? Start-Up Investment Checklist • Certificates and certifications • Licenses and permits • Insurance • Marketing materials • Payroll • Professional fees (accounting and legal) • Rent • Office supplies Start-Up Investment Checklist • Utilities • Website fees • Building and/or land (if purchased) • Leasehold improvements • Equipment (including installation) • Furniture and fixtures • Inventory (raw materials or finished goods) Start-Up Investment Checklist • Rent deposit • Signage • Utility deposits • Vehicles • Contingency funds (10%) Keeping a Reserve • Start-up investment should include one more thing: a cash reserve, an emergency fund of cash resources that equal at least half your start- up costs • For the previously mentioned hot dog cart example, the reserve would be half of $3,850, or $1,925, raising to $5,775 the total start-up sum required • Entrepreneurs must be prepared for the unexpected • The reserve will provide a moderate cushion of protection when you need it Keeping a Reserve • If your computer breaks down or your biggest supplier raises prices, you will be glad you had this money on hand • Having a cash reserve will also enable you to take advantage of opportunities • Assume that you own a vintage bed-and-breakfast property, and you hear from a friend whose elderly relative has died and left her some antique furniture • She is willing to sell you the furniture for $1,000 which you think would be perfect for your property • If you did not have extra cash on hand, you could not have purchased the furniture Predict the Payback Period • When compiling and analyzing start-up costs, one consideration will be how long it will take for you to earn back your start-up investment • The payback period is an estimate of how long it will take your business to bring in enough cash to cover the start-up investment • It is measured in months • Payback Period = Start-Up Investment/Net Cash Flow Per Month Predict the Payback Period: An Example • A small bubble tea café requires a start-up investment of $65,000 • The business is projecting a net cash flow per month of $13,000 • How many months will it take to make back the start-up investment? • Payback Period = Start-Up Investment/Net Cash Flow Per Month • What is the correct answer? Predict the Payback Period • Knowing the payback period is important for a start-up or an existing firm so that the time horizon is known, and the timing of funds availability is clear • The payback period does not take into account future earnings, opportunities for alternative investments, or the overall value of the company • It is only based upon net cash • It is a relatively good indicator of the time needed to earn back the initial funding Variable and Fixed Costs • Variable costs change based on the volume of units sold or produced • They are expenses that vary directly with changes in production or sales volume • Fixed costs are expenses that must be paid regardless of whether sales are being generated (or not) • Fixed costs are also referred to as fixed operating costs Variable Costs • There are two categories of variable costs • (1) Cost of goods sold (COGS) or cost of services sold (COSS) • The cost of materials used to make the product (or deliver the service) • The cost of labour used to make the product (or deliver the service) • (2) Other variable costs • Commissions or other compensation based on sales volume • Shipping and handling charges Fixed Costs • Fixed costs stay constant whether you sell many units or very few • They do not vary with changes in the volume of production or sales • There is rent to be paid as well as salaries, insurance, and equipment (rented or purchased) • A deli has to pay the same rent each month whether it sells one sandwich or a 1,000 sandwiches • However, the owner of the deli can change the cost of the rent by moving, or he/she can increase or decrease the advertising budget Fixed Costs • There are seven common fixed operating costs: • Utilities (gas, electricity, telephone service, and Internet service) • Salaries (indirect labour) • Advertising • Insurance • Interest • Rent • Depreciation (the percentage of value of an asset subtracted each year until the value become zero, to reflect wear and tear on the asset) Fixed Costs: They Sometimes Change Over Time • You pay our restaurant manager $5,500 per month in salary • You have to pay that amount whether the restaurant sells one meal or a several thousand • The cost is fixed • Fixed operating costs can change over time; at some point, you may give your restaurant manager a raise • You may hire a new manager at a lower salary (should your current manager resign) • The word “fixed” does not mean the cost never changes Fixed Costs: They Sometimes Change Over Time • (1) Advertising costs. The cost of advertising will change based on decisions the entrepreneur makes about how much to spend to reach consumers • The cost of advertising is not directly tied to current sales (though, poor sales may prompt an increase in advertising) • (2) Heating and cooling costs. The price of heating and cooling goes up or down • Factors such as the weather and utility prices play a role, not the amount of revenue the business earns The Dangers of Fixed Costs • If a business does not have enough sales to cover its fixed costs, it will lose money • If losses continue, the business will have to close • Fixed costs are “dangerous” (they represent a risk) because they must be paid whether or not the business is making enough sales/money to cover them • Variable costs, in contrast, do not threaten a business’s survival because they are proportional to sales The Impact of Inflation • Inflation is the gradual, continuous increase in the prices of products and services, usually resulting from a rise in the amount of money in circulation in an economy • If you save $2,000 per year to buy new tables and chairs (which cost $10,000 the last time you bought them) for your restaurant, but find at the end of five years that the cost of replacing them has risen to $15,000 because of inflation, you could find it a challenge to buy the much-needed replacements • Keep up with economic trends by reading the financial section in the newspapers as well as financial magazines • By staying up to date on what is happening, you can invest wisely Revenue Streams Modes of Revenue Generation • A revenue model helps determine how to convert the value your customer receives into money the customer gives to you • A revenue model is a company’s strategy for making money from the value it provides to customers • (1) You can sell products or services for purchase (a one-time transaction) • You can charge an admission fee for one visit • (2) You use a subscription-based model for the fees you charge (visitors can access your service as many times as they wish within the subscription period) • What about a weekly or monthly pass? Modes of Revenue Generation • (3) You can generate revenue by selling sponsored space (website space or physical space) • (4) In the “freemium” model, the product is initially free but, eventually, the user must pay to use the full product/have full functionality • (5) The “bait” model: You first sell a cheap product and then enable customers to buy expensive parts (for example, men’s razors) • (6) The license model: You invent something once and you make money on it again and again. A photographer takes a picture, and he/she can ask for money if other people use his/her picture to put on a website Modes of Revenue Generation • (7) The rental model: You use certain goods rarely, so it is often not worthwhile to buy them • In that case, some people own these goods and they, for a certain price, want to rent them to you for a certain period • (8) The consumption model: The customer pays for what he/she consumes. With gas and electric companies, you pay for the amount you consume • (9) The brokerage or commission model: PayPal receives a commission for every successful transaction that goes through its platform • (10) The bundle model: You sell a certain product and in doing so you immediately sell a related product. When you book a package vacation, you can sometimes buy travel insurance immediately Modes of Revenue Generation • (11) You create something customized for the customer. Consider a running shoe that can be personalized (with a name) or a customer formulating his or her own shampoo • (12) The donation model: People donate money to you. You are completely dependent on the goodwill people have because they are free to give how much they want. Wikipedia is built entirely around user donations • (13) The arbitrage model: You profit from the price difference between two markets supplying the same goods • You buy a product at a cheap price from one platform and sell it on a different platform (such as Amazon) in other countries What Price Will You Charge? • What price will you charge for your product or service? • Entrepreneurs should consider not only the economics of pricing but also the psychology of pricing • Simply undercutting your competitors’ prices will not necessarily win you the largest market share • Study the prices and pricing strategies of your (potential) competitors What Price Will You Charge? • (1) Value Pricing Strategy: It offers “more for less” by underscoring a product’s quality while at the same time featuring its price • Value pricing is not simply price cutting • It means finding the balance between quality and price that will give your target customers the value they seek • (2) Prestige Pricing Strategy: When a firm sets high prices on its products or services to send a message about premium quality, it is using a prestige pricing strategy What Price Will You Charge? • (3) Cost-Plus Pricing Strategy: This method is one of the most used pricing strategies; you take your cost and add a desired profit margin • It is the simplest approach to calculate once your costs are known and your desired rate of return is established • (4) Meet-or-Beat the Competition Pricing Strategy: It entails constantly matching or undercutting the prices of your competition • (5) Follow-the-Leader Pricing Strategy: It is similar to a meet-or-beat the competition pricing strategy but with a particular competitor as the model for pricing Today’s Key Questions • What costs are associated with the creation of a business? • What factors should entrepreneurs keep in mind when calculating the amount of money they will need for their start-up investment? • What are fixed costs and what are variable costs? How are they different from each other? • How do businesses generate revenue? Possible Quiz Question • Why is an understanding of money – costs as well as ways to earn revenue – important for entrepreneurs?