B I O T E C H N O L O G Y F O R D E V E L O P I N G A LT E R N AT I V E P R O T E I N

S O U R C E S : A C O M PA R AT I V E S T U D Y O F P L A N T- B A S E D A N D
C U LT U R E D M E AT P R O D U C T S

BY SAMEEKSHA DUBEY
 TABLE OF
BIOTECHNOLOGY

CONTENTS
OBJECTIVE OF THE STUDY
CASE STUDIES
ABSTRACT
INTRODUCTION
DEFINITION OF ALTERNATIVE PROTEIN SOURCES

PLANT-BASED MEAT PRODUCTS

CULTURED MEAT PRODUCTS

COMPARISON OF PLANT-BASED AND CULTURED MEAT PRODUCTS

CHALLENGES AND PROSPECTS

2
CONCLUSION
ALTERNATIVE PROTEIN
SOURCES
Alternative protein sources refer to protein
sources that are not traditionally derived
from animal products, such as plant-based
and cultured meat products.

PLANT-BASED MEAT PRODUCTS

CULTURED MEAT PRODUCTS

WHY IS THERE A
NEED FOR
ALTERNATIVE
PROTEINS?
ALTER NAT IVE PR OTEINS

To meet the increasing demand for

protein due to the growing
population.

To reduce the environmental impact

of traditional animal agriculture
practices.

To provide healthier and more

sustainable protein sources.
6
A s t h e w o r l d ' s p o p u l a t i o n c o n t i n u e s t o g r o w, t h e d e m a n d
for protein-rich foods is increasing.

H o w e v e r, t r a d i t i o n a l a n i m a l a g r i c u l t u r e p r a c t i c e s a r e
resource-intensive and have a significant environmental
impact.

Therefore, there is a need to explore alternative protein

sources to meet the growing demand for protein while
reducing the environmental impact of food production.
ALTERNATE PROTEIN

GROWING DEMAND FOR SUSTAINABLE AND

ETHICAL FOOD PRODUCTS:

• The demand for sustainable and ethical food products is driven by

concerns over animal welfare, environmental sustainability, and
human health. Consumers are increasingly looking for food
products that are produced using sustainable and ethical practices.

8
 E M E R G E N C E O F P L A N T- B A S E D A N D C U LT U R E D
ALTERNATE PROTEIN

M E AT P R O D U C T S A S A LT E R N AT I V E P R O T E I N
SOURCES:

• Plant-based and cultured meat products are emerging as popular

alternatives to conventional animal-based meat due to their
potential to address concerns over animal welfare, environmental
sustainability, and human health.

9
PRESENTATION TITLE

OBJECTIVE OF THE STUDY

The objective of this study is to compare
plant-based and cultured meat products as
alternative protein sources and to analyze
their potential for meeting the increasing
demand for protein.
10
 ABSTRACT
ABSTRACT

As concerns around traditional meat production's sustainability, animal

welfare, and health impacts have risen, the demand for alternative
protein sources is growing rapidly.
Biotechnology is a promising field that can offer solutions to these
concerns through the development of plant-based and cultured meat
products.
This study compares the processing background, significance,
challenges, and future prospects of plant-based and cultured meat
products.

11
ENVIRONMENTAL IM E N V I R O N M E N TA L I M PA C T O F T R A D I T I O N A L M E AT
• Traditional meat production has a significant environmental impact. Here are some of the main
environmental impacts of traditional meat production:
1. Land use: Animal agriculture requires vast amounts of land for grazing, feed production, and
PACT

other infrastructure, leading to deforestation and habitat destruction.

2. Water use: Animal agriculture is a highly water-intensive industry, with large amounts of water
required for animal feed production, drinking, and waste management.
3. Greenhouse gas emissions: Animal agriculture is a significant source of greenhouse gas
emissions, with the production of methane from livestock digestion and manure being a major
contributor.
4. Water pollution: Livestock waste can contaminate nearby water sources, leading to the
degradation of water quality and harm to aquatic life.
5. Biodiversity loss: The expansion of animal agriculture can lead to the displacement of wildlife,
resulting in a loss of biodiversity.
12 6. Antibiotic resistance: The routine use of antibiotics in animal agriculture can contribute to the
development of antibiotic-resistant bacteria, making it harder to treat infections in humans.
PRESENTATION TITLE
I M PA C T S O F T R A D I T I O N A L M E AT P R O D U C T I O N A N D H O W
A LT E R N AT I V E P R O T E I N S C A N H E L P M I T I G AT E T H E S E I M PA C T S

Animal welfare: Traditional meat production often involves inhumane treatment of animals, including
confinement, overcrowding, and other practices that can cause pain and suffering. Alternative protein sources,
such as plant-based and cultured meat, have the potential to improve animal welfare by reducing the need for
large-scale animal agriculture.

Health impacts: Consumption of traditional meat products has been linked to numerous health problems,
including heart disease, stroke, and certain types of cancer. Alternative protein sources, particularly plant-based
products, can provide a healthier alternative by being lower in saturated fat and cholesterol.

Resource depletion: Animal agriculture requires vast amounts of resources, including water, land, and feed.
This can lead to the depletion of these resources and contribute to food insecurity. Alternative protein sources,
such as plant-based products, are generally more resource-efficient and have the potential to provide a more
sustainable food source.

Economic impact: Traditional meat production is often associated with large corporations and can have a
negative impact on small-scale farmers and local economies. Alternative protein sources, particularly plant-
based products, have the potential to support local economies and provide opportunities for small-scale farmers
13
and entrepreneurs.
 CASE STUDIES BASED ON THE REVIEW OF
L I T E R AT U R E
CASE STUDIES

• Traditional meat production has been linked to a range of environmental impacts, including
deforestation, greenhouse gas emissions, water pollution, and land degradation (FAO, 2006).
• The production of beef, for example, has been identified as a major contributor to
deforestation in the Amazon rainforest (Nepstad et al., 2008).
• In addition, the production of meat is responsible for approximately 14.5% of global
greenhouse gas emissions (FAO, 2013).
• Alternative protein sources, such as plant-based and cultured meat, have the potential to
reduce the environmental impacts of meat production.
• For example, plant-based meat products have been shown to require significantly less land,
water, and energy to produce than traditional meat products (Tuomisto & Teixeira de Mattos,
2011).
• Cultured meat, which is produced using cell culture technology, has the potential to reduce
the environmental impacts of meat production even further (Post et al., 2012).
14
 CASE STUDIES BASED ON THE REVIEW OF
L I T E R AT U R E
CASE STUDIES

• Animal agriculture is also a major consumer of water resources, accounting for

approximately one-third of the world's freshwater consumption (FAO, 2018).
• Livestock production has been linked to water pollution through the release of excess
nutrients and pathogens from animal waste into waterways (Eshel et al., 2014).
• Furthermore, the overuse of antibiotics in animal agriculture has contributed to the
development of antibiotic-resistant bacteria, which is a significant public health concern
(FAO, 2018).
• Research has also shown that alternative protein sources have the potential to provide health
benefits over traditional meat.
• Plant-based protein sources have been linked to lower rates of chronic diseases such as heart
disease, diabetes, and certain cancers (Craig & Mangels, 2009).
• Furthermore, plant-based diets have been shown to be effective in preventing and treating
various chronic diseases (Kahleova et al., 2017).
15
Traditional meat production has been associated
with a range of environmental impacts and health
concerns.

Alternative protein sources, such as plant-based

and cultured meat, have the potential to reduce
these impacts while providing a sustainable and
healthy source of protein.
 INTRODUCTION
INTRODUCTION

The global meat industry is responsible for significant

environmental, social, and health impacts. It is a major
contributor to greenhouse gas emissions, deforestation,
water pollution, and biodiversity loss.

Additionally, animal welfare concerns and health risks

associated with the consumption of meat have also been
raised. These concerns have led to the development of
alternative protein sources such as plant-based and
cultured meat products.

17
PLANT-BASED MEAT
PLANT-BASED
MEAT PRODUCTS
Plant-based meat products are made from plant-based protein
sources such as soy, wheat, pea, and other legumes.

The process involves extracting the protein from these sources

and then processing it to form a texture like that of meat.

These products are often fortified with vitamins, minerals, and

other nutrients to make them nutritionally comparable to meat.

According to recent data, the global plant-based meat market is

expected to reach $14.3 billion by 2030, growing at a CAGR of
18
19.4% from 2020 to 2030.
PLANT BASED MEAT

Meat substitutes derived from plant-based

meat products can be classified into several
categories based on the protein source,
processing method, and application.
Here are some common classifications:

S O Y- B A S E D : T h e s e p r o d u c t s u s e s o y
protein as the primary source and are
often used in burgers, sausages, and
meatballs.

C L A S S I F I C AT I O N O F
P L A N T- B A S E D M E AT
PRODUCTS:
19
W H E AT- B A S E D : T h e s e p r o d u c t s u s e
wheat gluten as the primary protein source
and are often used in products such as
seitan and deli meats.
PEA-BASED: These products use pea
protein as the primary protein source and
are often used in products such as chicken
strips, nuggets, and patties.
PLANT BASED MEAT

NUT AND SEED-BASED: These products use

protein sources from nuts and seeds such as
almonds, cashews, sunflower seeds, and
pumpkin seeds and are used in a variety of
products such as veggie burgers and sausage
substitutes.

V E G E TA B L E - B A S E D : T h e s e p r o d u c t s u s e
vegetable protein sources such as mushrooms,
eggplants, and carrots to create meat-like
textures and flavors and are used in products
such as burgers, meatballs, and sausages.

HYBRID BLENDS: These products combine

multiple protein sources to create unique meat-
like textures and flavors. For example, a
p r o d u c t m a y c o m b i n e p e a , s o y, a n d m u s h r o o m
e x t r a c t s t o c r e a t e a m e a t - l i k e b u r g e r p a t t y.

C L A S S I F I C AT I O N O F OTHER LEGUME-BASED: These products use

protein sources from other legumes such as
P L A N T- B A S E D M E AT lentils, chickpeas, and beans and are used in a
variety of products such as ground meat
PRODUCTS: substitutes, roasts, and meatballs.

20
PLANT BASED MEAT

PLANT-BASED MEAT PRODUCTS:

Plant-based meat products are meat substitutes made from plant-based protein sources. These products are available in various types such as
burgers, sausages, nuggets, and meatballs. The processing methods and ingredients used in plant-based meat production vary depending on the
manufacturer.

Examples of popular plant-based meat products include Beyond Meat, Beyond Burger and Impossible Foods, Impossible Burger.

PROS AND CONS OF PLANT-BASED MEAT PRODUCTS:

The benefits of plant-based meat products include their potential to reduce environmental impact, improve animal welfare, and provide health
benefits. However, their taste and texture may not be as satisfactory as traditional meat, and some may contain high levels of sodium and
saturated fats.

FUTURE PROSPECTS AND CHALLENGES OF PLANT-BASED MEAT PRODUCTS:

The future prospects of plant-based meat products are promising, with an increasing number of consumers opting for plant-based diets.
However, challenges remain, including the need for continued innovation to improve taste and texture, and regulatory and marketing hurdles.

21
 GLOBAL OUTLOOK
GLOBAL OUTLOOK

22
MASS PRODUCTION T

MASS PRODUCTION TECHNIQUES

ECHNIQUES

EXTRUSION T E X T U R I Z AT I O N F E R M E N TAT I O N 3D PRINTING

23
MASS PRODUCTION TECHNIQUES

EXTRUSION
Extrusion is a common method used in the
production of plant-based meat products, such
as burgers, sausages, and chicken nuggets. This
process involves mixing the raw materials
(such as soy protein isolate or wheat gluten)
with water and other ingredients to form a
dough-like consistency. The dough is then fed
into an extruder machine, which uses a high-
pressure and temperature shape and cooks the
product.

T E X T U R I Z AT I O N
Texturization is another common method used
in the production of plant-based meat products,
particularly for products with a meat-like
MASS PRODUCTION texture such as seitan or chicken strips. This
process involves taking a high-protein
TECHNIQUES ingredient (such as wheat gluten or pea protein)
and using heat and pressure to alter its texture
24
and create a meat-like texture.
MASS PRODUCTION TECHNIQUES

F E RME N TAT I O N
Fermentation is a newer method being explored
in the production of plant-based meat products,
particularly for products with a more complex
flavor profile such as steak or bacon. This
process involves using microbes to ferment
plant-based ingredients such as soy, wheat, or
fungi to create a product with a meat-like taste
and texture.

3D PRINTING
3D printing is a relatively new technology
being explored in the production of plant-based
meat products. This process involves using a
printer to create meat-like structures from
plant-based ingredients, layer by layer. This
method allows for greater control over the
MASS PRODUCTION TECHNIQUES texture and structure of the final product but is
still in the experimental stage.
25
PLANT-BASED MEAT
CULTURED MEAT
PRODUCTS

Cultured meat products, also known as cell-based meat, are meat products that are
grown from animal cells in a lab. This technology allows for the production of
meat products without the need for animal slaughter.

There are two types of cultured meat products: scaffold-based and scaffold-free.

Scaffold-based products use a three-dimensional structure, such as a hydrogel, to

support the growth and differentiation of animal cells.

Scaffold-free products use bioreactors to cultivate the cells in a liquid medium.

Some examples of cultured meat products in development and on the market

include Memphis Meats' cultured chicken and Mosa Meat's cultured beef.
26
 Cultured meat products can also be classified based
on several criteria such as the source of cells, the
CLASSIFICATION

method of production, and the application. Some of

the commonly used categories are:
 Beef-Based: These products use bovine cells as the primary
cell source and are often used in products such as burgers,
meatballs, and steaks.

 Chicken-Based: These products use avian cells as the primary

cell source and are often used in products such as chicken
strips, nuggets, and patties.

 Seafood-Based: These products use cells from seafood such

as fish, shrimp, and crab and are used in products such as

C L A S S I F I C AT I O N O F seafood substitutes and sushi.

C U LT U R E D M E AT  Other Meat Types: These products use cells from other types
PRODUCTS: of meat such as pork, lamb, and venison and are used in a
27 variety of products such as sausages, hot dogs, and ground
meat substitutes.
 CULTURED MEAT PRODUCTS:
PLANT BASED MEAT

Cultured meat products, also known as lab-grown meat or cell-based meat, are produced using in vitro techniques. This involves
growing muscle cells in a lab setting and then combining them to create meat products.

Examples of cultured meat products in development and on the market include Memphis Meats' chicken and JUST Inc's GOOD
Meat.

PROS AND CONS OF CULTURED MEAT PRODUCTS:

The benefits of cultured meat products include their potential to address concerns over animal welfare and environmental
sustainability, as well as their ability to provide a consistent product. However, challenges remain in terms of regulatory approval,
consumer acceptance, and scalability.

FUTURE PROSPECTS AND CHALLENGES OF CULTURED MEAT PRODUCTS:

The future prospects of cultured meat products are promising, with growing investment and interest from major food companies.
However, challenges remain, including the need for continued technological innovation to improve taste and texture, and concerns
28 over the ethical and environmental implications of lab-grown meat.
 C E L L I S O L AT I O N
MASS PRODUCTION TECHNIQUES

The first step in producing in vitro meat is to isolate

animal cells from a biopsy or a live animal. This
involves extracting muscle cells from the animal's
tissue and then culturing them in a lab.

C E L L C U LT U R E
Once the cells are isolated, they are cultured in a
bioreactor. The bioreactor provides the cells with the
necessary nutrients, oxygen, and other factors needed
for growth. The cells are also stimulated with
electrical or chemical signals to help them
differentiate into muscle tissue.

SCAFFOLD PRODUCTION
MASS PRODUCTION To create meat with a realistic texture, the muscle
TECHNIQUES cells must be attached to a scaffold. The scaffold
provides a structure for the cells to grow around,
creating a meat-like structure. Scaffolds can be made
from natural or synthetic materials.

29
MASS PRODUCTION TECHNIQUES

MAT U R AT I O N

The cultured meat is then allowed to

mature in the bioreactor. During this time,
the muscle tissue develops and becomes
more like traditional meat in terms of
texture and flavour.

H A RV E S T I N G
MASS PRODUCTION Once the cultured meat has reached the
TECHNIQUES desired maturity, it is harvested. The meat
can be harvested in small quantities for
research purposes, or in larger quantities
for commercial production.
30
 COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
COMPARATIVE STUDY

31
COMPARATIVE STUD

Parameters of Comparison Plant Based Meat Cultured Meat

Definition Plant-based meat items are meat Cultured meat will be meat-filled in
analogs produced using plant research facilities from creature
protein. cells.
Y

Accessibility They have for some time been It isn’t yet industrially accessible.
important for the local diet regime.

Process The proteins are liable to warming, Cells multiply in the culture
expulsion, and cooling to medium.
manufacture meat-like surfaces.

Preservatives Different fixings and added Cells develop into muscle strands
substances are added to work on the under a controlled climate.
tangible profiles.
Uses Not just appropriate for making Just appropriate for making
32
handled or comminuted meat items handled/comminuted meat items.
CHALLENGES AND
PROSPECTS
 CHALLENGES
CHALLENGES

The development and mass production of alternative protein sources such as plant-
based meat and cultured meat face several challenges:
 Cost: one of the primary challenges facing the mass production of alternative
protein sources is the cost of production. The high cost of production is due to
the high cost of raw materials, processing techniques, and technology used in
production.
 Taste and texture: another challenge is developing alternative protein sources
that mimic the taste, texture, and appearance of traditional meat. Consumers are
often hesitant to try new products that don't have the same taste and texture as
meat.
 Regulatory approval: the production and sale of alternative protein sources
such as cultured meat are subject to regulatory approval from governmental
agencies such as the FDA and USDA. These agencies require extensive testing
and approval processes, which can be time-consuming and costly.
 Consumer acceptance: finally, the acceptance and adoption of alternative
protein sources depend on consumer awareness and education. Consumers must
34
be willing to try new products and be open to changing their dietary habits.
 PROSPECTS
CHALLENGES

Despite the challenges, the prospects for alternative protein sources such as plant-based
meat and cultured meat are promising:
 Environmental Sustainability: Alternative protein sources are more
environmentally sustainable than traditional meat production. Plant-based
meat and cultured meat have lower greenhouse gas emissions, require less
land and water, and produce less waste than traditional meat production.
 Health Benefits: Alternative protein sources such as plant-based meat and
cultured meat have health benefits over traditional meat. They are often lower
in saturated fat, calories, and cholesterol, and higher in fiber and nutrients.
 Growing Demand: The demand for alternative protein sources is increasing
due to the rising concern for animal welfare, environmental sustainability, and
health. As consumers become more aware of the benefits of alternative
protein sources, the demand for these products is expected to increase.
 Technological Advancements: Rapid advancements in technology are
improving the production process of alternative protein sources, leading to
35 lower costs and higher-quality products.
 P R E SE N T SC E N A R IO A N D GL OB A L OU T L OOK:
PRESENT SCENARIO

The plant-based and cultured meat industries have gained significant

traction in the global food market due to concerns about the sustainability
and ethical implications of traditional meat production.

The global plant-based meat market is expected to reach USD 8.3

billion by 2025, while the cultured meat market is expected to reach
USD 571.5 million by 2030.

The growth is driven by increasing consumer awareness and concerns,

advancements in biotechnology and food science, and the COVID-19
pandemic.

Challenges for both industries include taste and texture development,

cost competitiveness, and scaling up production.

Despite these challenges, the future outlook for the plant-based and
cultured meat industries looks promising as they offer sustainable and
36
ethical alternatives to traditional meat production.
 SUMMARY
PRESENTATION TITLE

The demand for alternative protein sources like plant-based meat and cultured meat is increasing
due to concerns for animal welfare, environmental sustainability, and health.

Challenges include cost, taste and texture, regulatory approval, and consumer acceptance.
However, the prospects for these products are promising due to their sustainability, health benefits,
growing demand, and technological advancements.

As technology improves, costs are expected to decrease, making these products more accessible.
Alternative protein sources have the potential to provide a sustainable, ethical, and healthy food
source for the future.

37
PRESENTATION TITLE

REFERENCES
• Tuomisto, H. L., & Teixeira, R. (2021). The environmental impacts of cultured meat production. Frontiers in Sustainable Food
Systems, 5, 582551. doi: 10.3389/fsufs.2021.582551

• Specht, E. A., Welch, D. R., & Miller, S. C. (2020). Opportunities for applying biomedical production and manufacturing methods to
the development of the clean meat industry. Bioengineering & Translational Medicine, 5(2), e10158. doi: 10.1002/btm2.10158

• Lynch, M. E., & Pierrehumbert, R. T. (2019). Climate impacts of cultured meat and beef cattle. Frontiers in Sustainable Food
Systems, 3, 5. doi: 10.3389/fsufs.2019.00005

• Wilks, M. (2021). Plant-based and cell-based meat substitutes: An analysis of current products and future developments. Food
Science and Technology International, 27(5), 349-361. doi: 10.1177/10820132211028005

• Stephens, N., Di Silvio, L., Dunsford, I., Ellis, M., Glencross, A., & Sexton, A. (2018). Bringing cultured meat to market: Technical,
socio-political, and regulatory challenges in cellular agriculture. Trends in Food Science & Technology, 78, 155-166. doi:
10.1016/j.tifs.2018.03.004

• Lynch, J. P., & Pierrehumbert, R. T. (2019). The economics of cultured meat. Journal of Agricultural Economics, 70(3), 741-758. doi:
10.1111/1477-9552.12317

• Bryant, C. J., Szejda, K., Parekh, N., Desphande, V., & Tse, B. (2021). Plant-based and cell-based meat substitutes: Assessment of
38 current products and production methods. International Journal of Food Science & Technology, 56(1), 1-11. doi: 10.1111/ijfs.14633
THANK YOU