Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Recent Bank Developments: FIN 653: Seminar in Bank Management
Recent Bank Developments: FIN 653: Seminar in Bank Management
< $100 M $310 (7.54%) $277 (5.97%) $243 (4.23%) $222 (3.37%) $201 (2.64%) $189 (2.25%)
> $10B $2,061 (50.07%) $2,658 (57.27%) $3,823 (66.65%) $4,613 (70.22%) $5,545 (72.93%) $6,297 (74.85%)
ROE of Different Size Banks, 1990-2000 All $0m$100m $1b$10b Year Banks $100m -$1b -$10b and above ____________________________________________________ 1990 7.64% 9.02% 9.95 10.25% 6.68% 1991 8.05 9.40 10.51 7.50 7.35 1992 13.24 11.93 12.60 12.52 13.86 1993 15.67 12.29 13.61 14.02 16.81 1994 14.90 12.01 13.49 14.19 15.73 1995 14.68 11.37 13.48 15.04 15.60 1996 14.40 11.69 13.63 14.82 14.93 1997 14.71 11.57 14.50 14.30 15.32 1998 13.95 10.15 13.57 15.96 13.82 1999 15.34 9.07 14.24 16.02 15.97 2000 14.07 9.09 13.56 14.57 14.42 ________________________________________________________
1990 1993 1996 1999 _________________________________________________________ Number of banks 12,370 11,001 9,576 8,698 Total assets $4.22 $4.23 $4.80 $5.47 % held by fifty largest BHCs 55.3 % 59.7 % 66.6 % 68.1% %held by ten largest BHCs 25.6 % 31.6 % 38.5 % 44.8 % Total domestic deposits $2.93 $2.76 $2.85 $3.08 % held by fifty largest BHCs 48.0% 51.4% 56.9% 58.2% % held by ten largest BHCs 17.3 % 22.0 % 26.2 % 33.6 % _________________________________________________________ Source: Consolidated Reports of Condition and Income, 1990-99.
Maximum interest rates that could be paid on deposits or charged on loans; Minimum capital-to-asset ratios; Minimum legal reserve requirements; Limited geographic markets for full-service banking; Constraints on the type of investments permitted, and restrictions on the range of products and services offered.
1. Deregulation/Re-regulation CAMELS System: Capital Asset Quality Management Quality Earning Quality Liquidity Sensitivity to Market Risk
1. Deregulation/Re-regulation Banks and other market participants have consistently restructured their operations to circumvent regulation and meet perceived customer need. In response, regulators or lawmakers would impose new restrictions, which market participants circumvented again. This process of regulation and market response (financial innovation) and imposition of new regulations (re-regulation) is the regulatory dialectic.
1. Deregulation/Re-regulation Today banks are accessing the formerly forbidden areas of investment banking, by the repeal of the Glass-Steagall Act via the Financial Services Modernization Act (Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act of 1999).
Pricing issues: removing price controls on the maximum interest rates paid to depositories and the rate charged to borrowers (usury ceilings). Allowable geographic market penetration: The Riegle-Neal Interstate Banking and Branching Efficiency Act of 1994 has eliminated branching restrictions. New Products and services: Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act of 1999 has dramatically expanded the banks product choices; i.e., insurance, brokerage services, and securities underwriting.
Does not prevent bank failures Cannot eliminate economic risk Does not guarantee that bank management will make good decisions
Non-bank financial institutions especially finance companies, foreign institutions, and the public capital markets, have increased their market share in commercial lending at the expense of domestic commercial banks. Non-financial institutions, such as Sears, AT&T, and General Motors, have increased their market share in consumer lending at the expense of the banks.
MMMFs were created by investment banks in 1973 and grew from $10.4 b in 1978 to almost $189 b in 1981. Congress passed legislation enabling banks and thrifts to offer similar accounts including money market deposit accounts (MMDAs) and Super NOWS.
Commercial paper Captive automobile finance companies Other finance companies Junk bonds
Competition for payment services is coming from emerging electronic payment systems, such as:
Smart and stored-value cards Automatic bill payment Bill presentment processing Cash money can be acquired at any teller machine Open a checking account, apply for a loan and receive funds electronically
Underwriter syndicate
Trust services Brokerage Data Processing Securities underwriting Real estate appraisal Credit life insurance Personal financial consulting
3. Financial Innovation
Innovations take the form of new securities and financial markets, new products and services, new organizational forms, and new delivery systems.
Regulation Q brought about financial innovation as depository institutions tried to slow disintermediation. Banks developed new vehicles to compete with Treasury bills, money market mutual funds, and cash management accounts. Recent innovations take the form of new futures, options, options-on-futures, and the development of markets for a wide range of securitized assets.
3. Financial Innovation One competitive response to asset quality problems and earnings pressure has been to substitute fee income for interest income by offering more feebased services. Banks also lower their capital requirements and reduce credit risk by selling assets and servicing the payments between borrower and lender rather than holding the same assets to earn interest. This process of converting assets into marketable securities is called securitization.
4. Off-Balance-Sheet Activities
Loan Commitments Loan guarantees Standby Letters of Credit Interest Rate Swaps Futures, Forwards & Options Leases
Securitization
Securitization is the process of converting assets into marketable securities. It enables banks to move assets off-balancesheet and increase fee income. It increases competition for standardized produces such as mortgages and other cerditscored loans.
Securitization would not be possible without the servicing software that controls and monitors cash flows.
Investors trade pools of credit card loans because they can assess default risk without knowing the creditworthiness of each borrower. Swaps, swaptions, collars and caps are feasible and easier to use because computer pricing models narrow the bounds of mispricing and other errors.
(2). Derivative products for risk management: Banks' risk management has been improved with the striking advances in information technology:
Artificial intelligence software can narrow the role of human judgment in the management of credit risk.
(3). Internet banking had reduced costs substantially; (4). New technology had relaxed the geographical market and product constraints, which led to a greater market consolidation.
1. If loans are more liquid, then banks' private information about these loans and their role in monitoring the loans are both diminished. 2. If loans are securitized, any broker should be able to pool loans, issue traded claims against the pool, collecting interest and principal, and disbursing it to claim-holders. 3. If the bank's clients can manage interest risk with derivatives, why should they pay the bank for such protection?
6. Globalization The gradual evolution of markets and institutions so that geographic boundaries do not restrict financial transactions. Firms must recognize that businesses in other countries as well as their own are competitors, and that international events affect domestic operations.
Bank 1. Mizuho Financial Group 2. Citigroup 3. UBS Group 4. Credit Agricole Mutual 5. HSBC Holdings
6. Deutsche Bank
7. BNP paribus 8. Mitibush Tokyo Financial Group 9. Sumitomo Mitsui Financial Group 10. Royal Bank of Scotland
Germany
France Japan Japan United Kingdom
1,014,845
988,982 974.950 950,448 806,207
Bank 11. Barclays Bank 12. Credit Suisse Group 13. J.P. Morgan Chase 14. UFJ Holdings 15. Bank of America
Netherlands
France Netherlands United Kingdom China
684,004
681,218 667,636 650,721 637,829