Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Physico-Chemical Quality of Groundwater in Relation To Surface Water Pollution in Majidun Area of Ikorodu, Lagos State, Nigeria.
The Physico-Chemical Quality of Groundwater in Relation To Surface Water Pollution in Majidun Area of Ikorodu, Lagos State, Nigeria.
OF GROUNDWATER IN RELATION TO
SURFACE WATER POLLUTION IN
MAJIDUN AREA OF IKORODU, LAGOS
STATE, NIGERIA.
2012
1.0. INTRODUCTION
Much of the current concern with regards
to environmental quality is focused on
water because of its importance in
maintaining the human health and health
of the ecosystem. Fresh water is finite
resource, essential for agriculture, industry
and even human existence, without fresh
water of adequate quantity and quality,
sustainable development will not be
possible (Kumar, 1997).
. RUS
3.2. Experimental
TABLE 3.1: Water Sample Sources and GPS Location
Water Source
Symbol
GPS Location
Distance
(m)
Sample
No.
Dry
Wet
Total depth
(m)
01
River (Upstream)
RUS
N 6o 37' 9.3'' E 3o
28' 8.7''
0.0
02
River (Downstream)
RDS
N 6o 37' 7.1'' E 3o
28' 8.4''
70.38
03
Hand-dug Well
HDW-1
N 6o 37' 10.0'' E 3o
28' 4.7''
127.62
9.7
5.8
12.0
04
Hand-dug Well
HDW-2
N 6o 37' 8.4'' E 3o
28' 3.9''
139.82
4.8
1.5
8.0
05
Hand-dug Well
HDW-3
N 6o 37' 9.0'' E 3o
28' 2.4''
189.76
3.6
0.7
6.0
06
Hand-dug Well
HDW-4
N 6o 37' 10.5'' E 3o
28' 1.9''
203.08
3.8
0.8
6.6
07
Borewell
BW-1
N 6o 37' 11.1'' E 3o
28' 11.2''
79.90
08
Borewell
BW-2
N 6o 37' 12.6'' E 3o
28' 0.4''
254.12
Method
Procedure/ Equipment
Sample
volume(ml)
Unit
Temperature
Instrumentation
Mercury-in-glass
bulb thermometer
oC
pH
Instrumentation
pH-meter
Conductivity
Instrumentation
Conductivity meter
uS/cm
Colour
(True and
Apparent)
Colorimetric
Colorimeter (Wavelength =
430nm)
10
Pt-Co
Turbidity
Nephelometric
Colorimeter (Wavelength =
540 nm)
10
NTU
Total dissolved
solids (TDS)
Gravimetric
100
mgL-1
TABLE 3.3: Titrimetric methods for the analysis of Chemical parameters of Water Quality
Water
quality Parameter
Method
Titrant and
Indicator
Volume
Used(ml)
Colour Change
Unit
-1
Titration
and
Mixed indicator
(Bromocresol green
and Methyl red)
Chloride (Cl-)
MohrTitration
Hg(NO3)2
and Diphenylcarbazonebromo phenol blue
50
Yellow to
Purple
mgL-1
Calcium
Complexio-metric
Titration
Na2EDTA
and
Calcon indicator
50
Purple to
Light blue
mgL-1
Magnesium
Complexiometric
titration
Na2EDTA
and
Eriochrome
Black-T indicator
50
Purple to
Light blue
mgL-1
Total hardness
Complexiometric
titration
Na2EDTA
and
Eriochrome
Black-T indicator
25
Wine red to
Light blue
Organic carbon,
Organic matter
(TOM), and Chemical
oxygen demand
(COD)
Ferrous ammonium
sulphate
and
Barium diphenylamine
sulphonate
100
Yellow to
Light green
mgL-1
mgL-1
Instrument used
Wavelength (nm)
Unit
Sodium (Na+)
Flame emission
Spectrophotometer (FES)
589.0
mgl-1
Potassium (K+)
Flame emission
Spectrophotometer (FES)
766.0
mgl-1
Sulphate (SO42-)
Turbidimetric
(Turbidity meter)
540.0
mgl-1
Phosphate (PO43-)
Turbidimetric
(Turbidity meter)
882.0
mgl-1
Nitrate (NO3
2-)
Turbidimetric
(Turbidity meter)
420.0
mgl-1
4.0. RESULT
TABLE 4.1:Mean and standard error of mean of physical and chemical variables investigated in dry
season for river water, hand-dug wells and bore wells in Majidun area of Ikorodu, Lagos
Parameters
Permissible
Limit
(WHO)
RUS
RDS
HDW-1
HDW-2
HDW-3
HDW-4
BW-1
BW-2
Temp (oC)
Ambient
28.050.05
28.100.10
27.800.10
28.000.10
27.650.15
27.700.10
28.100.10
27.650.05
pH
6.5-8.5
6.900.10
6.850.25
7.150.15
6.800.00
7.450.05
7.350.05
6.850.25
6.900.40
App.C (Pt.Co)
15
139.9632.
01
171.5832.
33
171.5832.
33
27.9815.9
9
27.9815.9
9
43.970.00
43.970.00
0.000.00
Tr.C (Pt.Co)
15
27.9815.9
9
43.970.00
27.9815.9
9
11.990.00
6.006.00
11.990.00
11.990.00
0.000.00
Turb (NTU)
8.534.90
11.804.90
21.601.63
3.643.26
11.801.63
3.643.26
6.900.00
0.370.00
EC (S/cm)
1000
13880.00
5350.00
13730.00
5090.00
4290.001
50.00
2040.003
0.00
1880.001
0.00
1900.008
0.00
1620.000.
00
60.000.00
TDS (mg/L)
500
8883.204
324.00
8787.003
257.60
2745.696.
00
1305.601
9.20
1203.206.
40
1216.005
1.20
1036.800.
00
38.400.00
Alk (mg/L)
50-200
48.008.00
44.008.00
33.001.00
27.001.00
29.001.00
24.002.00
25.001.00
23.001.00
TH (mg/L)
500
1470.232
38.62
1494.435
4.32
1366.302
76.85
1039.852
27.65
1393.632
18.28
1276.482
18.28
981.2826
7.48
842.6549.
20
TOC (mg/L)
1.0
0.130.00
0.240.02
0.180.02
0.660.12
0.110.01
0.120.00
0.130.01
0.070.00
TOM (mg/L)
3.0
0.280.04
0.420.04
0.320.02
1.130.21
0.190.02
0.200.01
0.220.02
0.130.01
COD (mg/L)
5.0
0.360.02
0.650.06
0.490.04
1.750.32
0.290.03
0.310.02
0.340.03
0.200.02
TABLE 4.1 continued: Mean and standard error of mean of physical and chemical variables
investigated in dry season for river water, hand-dug wells and bore wells in Majidun area of Ikorodu,
Lagos
Parameters
Permiss
ible
Limit
(WHO)
RUS
RDS
HDW-1
HDW-2
HDW-3
HDW-4
BW-1
BW-2
K+ (mg/L)
50
45.501
5.50
45.501
5.25
26.000
.00
27.751
.25
17.630
.88
30.381
.12
14.250
.25
1.380.
12
Na+ (mg/L)
200
926.00
238.00
1009.00
274.00
434.50
35.50
151.00
11.00
145.50
5.50
150.00
5.00
162.00
6.00
11.000
.00
Mg2+ (mg/L)
250
306.00
30.00
318.00
18.00
318.00
66.00
246.00
54.00
330.00
54.00
306.00
54.00
234.00
66.00
204.00
12.00
Ca2+ (mg/L)
200
86.254
6.25
76.255
1.25
25.002
.50
12.502
.50
16.251
.25
8.751.
25
8.751.
25
2.500.
00
Cl- (mg/L)
250
32684.9
010138
.70
37438.3
07937.
70
4573.06
63.81
1396.73
35.45
1318.74
155.98
1191.12
85.08
1474.72
28.36
247.33
34.63
SO42- (mg/L)
100
6.141.3
5
8.525.
10
1.270.
03
1.600.
76
3.820.
06
4.080.
87
1.100.
08
1.020.
28
PO43- (mg/L)
100
1.571.1
4
1.101.
07
0.720.
10
0.860.
16
1.480.
55
1.200.
46
0.580.
18
1.260.
55
NO3- (mg/L)
45
0.960.0
0
0.330.
12
0.960.
25
0.580.
12
0.460.
00
0.230.
23
0.230.
23
0.100.
10
TABLE 4.2: Mean and standard error of mean of physical and chemical variables investigated in wet
season for river water, hand-dug wells and bore wells in Majidun area of Ikorodu, Lagos.
Parameters
Permissib
le Limit
(WHO)
RUS
RDS
HDW-1
HDW-2
HDW-3
HDW-4
BW-1
BW-2
Temp (oC)
Ambient
26.550.
35
26.350.
35
26.150.
05
26.100.
20
26.200.
00
26.200.
10
26.300.
20
26.300.
10
pH
6.5-8.5
6.650.5
5
6.450.4
5
6.400.4
0
6.700.0
0
7.100.2
0
6.600.0
0
6.800.3
0
6.100.2
0
App.C (Pt.Co)
15
219.901
6.00
251.871
5.99
59.9716
.00
11.990.
00
6.006.0
0
27.9815
.99
91.9616
.00
6.006.0
0
Tr.C (Pt.Co)
15
75.9631
.99
107.953
1.99
11.990.
00
11.990.
00
0.000.0
0
11.990.
00
11.990.
00
0.000.0
0
Turb (NTU)
18.341.
64
18.334.
90
13.443.
26
2.001.6
3
3.643.2
6
5.261.6
4
8.942.0
4
2.001.6
3
EC (S/cm)
1000
3050.00
2690.00
2925.00
2525.00
3350.00
510.00
1860.00
330.00
2340.00
410.00
1620.00
320.00
1540.00
140.00
165.009
5.00
TDS (mg/L)
500
1830.00
1614.00
1755.00
1515.00
2010.00
306.00
1116.00
198.00
1404.00
246.00
972.001
92.00
924.008
4.00
99.0057
.00
Alk (mg/L)
50-200
13.001.
00
16.505.
50
73.0017
.00
80.007.
00
92.0012
.00
93.0020
.00
74.0010
.00
13.002.
00
TH (mg/L)
500
258.141
72.10
241.321
26.58
358.071
47.03
402.921
70.78
534.561
20.24
452.782
08.14
229.404
4.88
365.202
39.32
TOC (mg/L)
1.0
4.570.2
2
4.180.3
3
4.340.0
6
4.820.1
2
4.260.2
1
4.160.2
0
4.340.0
2
3.640.8
4
TOM (mg/L)
3.0
7.880.3
7
7.210.5
7
7.480.1
0
8.320.2
0
7.340.3
6
7.180.3
4
7.480.0
3
6.271.4
4
COD (mg/L)
5.0
12.200.
58
11.160.
88
11.570.
16
12.880.
31
11.360.
56
11.100.
52
11.580.
04
9.702.2
3
TABLE 4.2 continued: Mean and standard error of mean of physical and chemical variables
investigated in wet season for river water, hand-dug wells and bore wells in Majidun area of Ikorodu,
Lagos.
Parameters
Permissi
ble
Limit
(WHO)
RUS
RDS
HDW1
HDW-2
HDW-3
HDW-4
BW-1
BW-2
K+ (mg/L)
50
13.751
0.00
13.009
.25
34.13
1.62
26.123
.88
24.003
.50
30.252
.25
15.000
.00
3.382.
12
Na+ (mg/L)
200
265.50
234.50
259.00
231.00
219.00
121.0
0
112.00
43.00
140.50
30.50
105.50
24.50
139.50
13.50
9.751.
25
Mg2+ (mg/L)
250
52.293
2.83
49.712
3.25
58.37
38.91
69.314
0.13
89.983
1.62
81.475
2.29
49.861
0.94
87.555
8.37
Ca2+ (mg/L)
200
17.501
5.00
15.001
2.50
47.50
5.00
47.502
.50
66.253
.75
47.502
.50
10.000
.00
2.500.
00
Cl- (mg/L)
250
2906.90
2495.6
8
3417.38
2991.9
8
2396.4
21020
.96
1120.22
70.90
1155.67
475.03
744.45
177.25
1269.06
347.44
233.97
21.27
SO42- (mg/L)
100
24.968
.11
19.667
.80
22.46
7.48
16.220
.00
53.200
.80
21.720
.74
6.242.
50
7.182.
80
PO43- (mg/L)
100
1.420.
42
1.680.
56
2.942.
16
1.200.
84
2.211.
46
1.641.
22
1.680.
36
1.640.
81
NO3- (mg/L)
45
1.080.
12
1.080.
37
1.580.
87
1.450.
99
1.330.
87
1.700.
25
0.830.
12
0.830.
12
TABLE 4.3: Mean and standard error of mean of physical and chemical variables
investigated in dry and wet seasons for river water, hand-dug wells and bore wells.
Parameters
Permissibl
e Limit
(WHO)
RUS
RDS
HDW-1
HDW-2
HDW-3
HDW-4
BW-1
BW-2
Temp (oC)
Ambient
27.300.4
6
27.220.5
3
26.980.
48
27.050.5
6
26.920.4
2
26.950.4
4
27.200.5
3
26.980.3
9
pH
6.5-8.5
6.780.24
6.650.24
6.780.2
8
6.750.03
7.280.13
7.020.19
6.820.16
6.500.29
App.C (Pt.Co)
15
179.932
7.31
211.732
7.46
115.773
5.43
19.988.0
0
16.999.4
3
35.988.0
0
67.9615.
31
3.003.00
Tr.C (Pt.Co)
15
51.9720.
12
75.9622.
62
19.998.
00
11.990.0
0
3.003.00
11.990.0
0
11.990.0
0
0.000.00
Turb (NTU)
13.433.5
3
15.063.4
0
17.522.
79
2.821.56
7.722.79
4.451.56
7.921.02
1.180.82
EC (S/cm)
1000
8465.00
3968.69
8327.50
3887.11
3820.00
347.47
1950.00
144.91
2110.00
213.70
1760.00
157.06
1580.00
61.64
112.504
9.22
TDS (mg/L)
500
5356.60
2556.12
5271.102
504.43
2377.80
249.47
1210.80
97.93
1303.60
115.99
1094.00
107.43
980.404
7.29
68.7029.
11
Alk (mg/L)
50-200
30.5010.
63
30.258.8
7
53.0013
.48
53.5015.
57
60.5018.
84
58.5021.
54
49.5014.
73
18.003.0
3
TH (mg/L)
500
864.183
69.94
867.873
66.09
862.193
17.94
721.382
17.50
964.092
68.05
864.632
67.77
605.342
43.66
603.931
70.13
TOC (mg/L)
1.0
2.351.28
2.211.14
2.261.2
0
2.741.20
2.191.20
2.141.17
2.231.22
1.861.08
TOM(mg/L)
3.0
4.082.20
3.821.97
3.902.0
7
4.722.08
3.772.07
3.692.02
3.852.10
3.201.87
COD(mg/L)
5.0
6.283.42
5.903.06
6.023.2
0
7.313.22
5.833.20
5.703.12
5.963.24
4.952.89
TABLE 4.3 continued: Mean and standard error of mean of physical and chemical
variables investigated in dry and wet seasons for river water, hand-dug wells and bore
wells
Parameters
Permissibl
e Limit
(WHO)
RUS
RDS
HDW-1
HDW-2
HDW-3
HDW-4
BW-1
BW-2
K+ (mg/L)
50
29.621
1.86
29.2511.
88
30.062.
44
26.941.
73
20.812.
36
30.311.
03
14.620.
24
2.381.0
4
Na+ (mg/L)
200
595.75
234.44
634.002
61.31
326.758
0.75
131.502
1.33
143.001
2.73
127.751
6.41
150.758
.86
10.380.
62
Mg2+ (mg/L)
250
179.14
75.46
183.867
8.37
188.188
1.21
157.665
7.93
209.997
3.84
193.747
1.71
141.935
9.76
145.774
1.50
Ca2+ (mg/L)
200
51.882
8.07
45.6227.
86
36.256.
88
30.0010
.21
41.2514
.52
28.1211
.24
9.380.6
2
2.500.0
0
Cl- (mg/L)
250
17796.0
09595.
02
20428.00
10413.7
0
3484.70
754.46
1258.50
86.13
1237.20
209.48
967.781
51.88
1371.90
154.20
240.651
7.03
SO42- (mg/L)
100
15.556
.39
14.094.9
8
11.876.
84
8.914.2
3
28.5214
.26
12.905.
11
3.671.8
0
4.102.1
2
PO43-(mg/L)
100
1.500.
50
1.390.52
1.831.0
9
1.020.3
6
1.840.6
7
1.420.5
5
1.120.3
6
1.450.4
1
NO3- (mg/L)
45
1.020.
06
0.710.27
1.270.4
1
1.020.4
8
0.890.4
4
0.960.4
5
0.530.2
0
0.470.2
2
Fig. 4.1. Graphical Presentation of the Mean Seasonal Variation in the Physicochemical parameters of the water samples for Temp., pH, Total hardness and
True color.
Fig. 4.2. Graphical Presentation of the Mean Seasonal Variation in the Physicochemical parameters of the water samples for App.color, Turbidity, Conductivity, and
Alkalinity.
Fig. 4.3. Graphical Presentation of the Mean Seasonal Variation in the Physicochemical parameters of the water samples for TDS, TOC, TOM and COD.
Fig. 4.4. Graphical Presentation of the Mean Seasonal Variation in the Physicochemical parameters of the water samples for Chloride, Sulphate, Phosphate
and Nitrate ions.
Fig. 4.5. Graphical Presentation of the Mean Seasonal Variation in the Physicochemical parameters of the water samples for Potassium, Sodium, Magnssium
and Calcium ions.
TABLE 4.4. ANOVA of the physico-chemical parameters between seasons (dry and wet) for River
Majidun.
Samples
Parameters
Temperature (oC)
18.000
0.051
23.113
0.041*
pH
0.200
0.698
0.604
0.518
Conductivity (S/cm)
3.271
0.212
3.616
0.198
426.380
0.002**
139.449
0.007**
417.040
0.002**
141.207
0.007**
423.713
0.002**
141.980
0.007**
8.134
0.104
16.084
0.057
5.240
0.149
1.428
0.355
0.015
0.913
0.231
0.678
1.000
0.423
3.606
0.198
2.963
0.227
3.320
0.210
3.908
0.187
4.380
0.171
32.545
0.029*
83.255
0.012*
1.999
0.293
1.348
0.365
3.472
0.203
3.381
0.189
Turbidity (NTU)
3.306
0.198
0.888
0.445
Alkalinity (mg/l)
18.846
0.049*
8.024
0.105
16.973
0.054
82.767
0.012*
4.991
0.115
4.958
0.156
1.800
0.312
4.000
0.184
TABLE 4.5. ANOVA of the physico-chemical parameters between seasons (dry and wet) for Hand dug wells
Samples
Parameters
HDW-1
F
Sig.
HDW-2
F
Sig.
HDW-3
F
Sig.
HDW-4
F
Temp (oC)
217.800
0.005**
72.200
0.014*
93.444
0.011*
112.500
0.009**
pH
3.082
0.221
2.882
0.232
169.000
0.006**
E. C (S/cm)
3.127
0.219
0.295
0.641
1.258
0.379
0.721
0.485
TOC (mg/l)
4584.000
0.000**
602.735
0.002**
381.014
0.003**
431.078
0.002**
TOM (mg/l)
4400.000
0.000**
614.698
0.002**
383.117
0.003**
433.124
0.002**
COD (mg/l)
4315.000
0.000**
615.817
0.002**
383.149
0.003**
430.603
0.002**
Cl-(mg/l)
4.528
0.167
12.168
0.073
0.106
0.775
5.161
0.151
SO42-(mg/l)
8.018
0.105
370.056
0.003**
3840.000
0.000**
238.536
0.004**
PO43-(mg/l)
1.040
0.415
0.157
0.731
0.219
0.686
0.111
0.771
NO3- (mg/l)
0.472
0.563
0.753
0.477
1.000
0.423
18.962
0.049*
K+(mg/l)
25.000
0.038*
0.159
0.728
3.122
0.219
0.002
0.965
Na+ (mg/l)
2.921
0.230
0.772
0.472
0.026
0.887
3.167
0.217
Mg2+ (mg/l)
11.483
0.077
6.897
0.120
14.713
0.062
8.922
0.096
Ca2+ (mg/l)
16.200
0.057
98.000
0.010*
160.000
0.006**
192.200
0.005**
TDS (mg/l)
5.261
0.149
0.908
0.441
0.666
0.500
1.508
0.344
Turb (NTU)
5.006
0.155
0.201
0.698
5.006
0.155
0.199
0.699
Alk (mg/l)
5.517
0.143
56.180
0.017*
27.372
0.035*
11.785
0.075
TH (mg/l)
10.345
0.085
5.009
0.155
11.883
0.075
7.459
0.112
AC (Pt.Co)
9.575
0.090
1.000
0.423
1.657
0.327
1.000
0.423
TC (Pt.Co)
1.000
0.423
1.000
0.423
Sig.
TABLE 4.6. ANOVA of the physico-chemical parameters between seasons (dry and
wet) for Bore wells
Samples
Parameters
BW-1
F
BW-2
F
Temperature (oC)
64.800
0.015*
145.800
0.007**
pH
0.016
0.910
3.200
0.216
Conductivity (S/cm)
0.327
0.625
1.222
0.384
36900
0.000**
18.174
0.051
40540
0.000**
18.180
0.051
43150
0.000**
18.190
0.051
0.348
0.615
0.108
0.774
4.230
0.176
4.773
0.161
7.226
0.115
0.151
0.735
Nitrate (mg/l)
5.344
0.147
20.332
0.046*
9.000
0.095
0.883
0.447
2.320
0.267
1.000
0.423
7.576
0.111
3.819
0.190
1.000
0.423
1.803
0.311
1.130
0.399
Turbidity (NTU)
1.000
0.423
1.000
0.423
Alkalinity (mg/l)
23.772
0.040*
20.000
0.047*
7.685
0.109
3.819
0.190
9.000
0.095
1.000
0.423
Sig.
Sig.
River and BW
Sig.
BW and HDW
Sig.
Temperature (oC)
0.751
0.923
0.957
pH
0.429
0.973
0.297
Conductivity (S/cm)
0.003**
0.001**
0.619
0.999
0.976
0.955
0.999
0.975
0.955
0.999
0.976
0.955
0.001**
0.002**
0.973
0.992
0.288
0.158
0.984
0.963
0.885
Nitrate (mg/l)
0.825
0.536
0.174
0.897
0.006**
0.005**
0.001**
0.001**
0.633
0.994
0.837
0.729
0.517
0.025*
0.109
0.003**
0.001**
0.639
Turbidity (NTU)
0.101
0.018*
0.440
Alkalinity (mg/l)
0.112
0.971
0.184
0.998
0.612
0.555
0.000**
0.000**
0.869
0.000**
0.000**
0.833
5.0. DISCUSSION
The physico-chemical water quality of surface
and groundwater resources in Majidun area of
Ikorodu, Lagos State.
The seasonal variation pattern in surface and
groundwater quality in the area.
The effect of surface water pollution on the
physico-chemical quality of the groundwater
resource.
Interrelationship study between the physicochemial parameters of the water sources.
5.1. CONCLUSION
The result of the river water quality
indicated that it is highly polluted and
unsafe (above WHO limits) for human use.
The hand dug wells and the closest bore
well to the river are relatively polluted with
significant variations between the two major
seasons. The quality of farthest bore well
(BW-2) to the river indicated that it is within
the WHO permissible limit to be used for
various purposes.
Conclusion cotinued